How to Teach Predicting Products Without Confusing Subscripts and Coefficients

               Predicting the products of chemical reactions — especially double displacement reactions — can overwhelm first-year chemistry students.  The confusion usually comes from mixing two different skills: writing stable compounds and balancing equations.  Sometimes all it takes is for a single phrase to click in their brain.  I added a new phrase this year that helped students know the difference between writing valid compounds and balancing equations.  This distinction is especially powerful when teaching double displacement reactions and balancing chemical equations.

The phrase that changed my classroom

Subscripts are for stability.

Coefficients are for counting.

These two sentences separate chemical reasoning (writing correct compounds) from arithmetic reasoning (balancing atoms). When students confuse the two, they struggle. When they separate them, predicting reactions becomes systematic.    

Step 1: Build Stability (Subscripts)

Subscripts are for stability.

Teaching stability first is the key to helping students predict products accurately.  Chemical reactions proceed toward greater stability.  When students predict products, their first question should not be “Is it balanced?” but “Is it stable?”

  In ionic reactions, stable compounds form when positive and negative charges balance to create neutral formulas.  Students create stable compounds by using subscripts to balance charges.  Subscripts are for stability.

Here is an example

K₂CO₃ (aq) + Al(NO₃)₃ (aq) →

To complete the double displacement reaction, students must construct stable products by adjusting subscripts.  Swap ions and build neutral compounds:

K⁺ and CO₃²⁻ → K₂CO₃

Al³⁺ and CO₃²⁻ → LCM of 6 → Al₂(CO₃)₃

(Here is a blog describing the LCM method for writing ionic formulas.)

Now the products are stable, and their states can be predicted using solubility rules.  (If you would like a copy of my free solubility rules, use this link.)

It helps the students to focus SOLELY on stability in order to write the products.  Young chemistry students often try to balance equations at the same time as writing compounds.  This almost always produces incorrect formulas or illegal subscripts.   Students often try to preserve the subscripts from the reactant side because they are thinking about conservation of matter too early.  But conservation is handled with coefficients — not subscripts.  If you teach subscripts for stability, the students are only trying to make stable compounds.

Step 2: Count Atoms (Coefficients)

Coefficients are for counting.

Once the products are stable, then it’s time to balance the reaction.  Students do that by counting atoms on the left and right of the equation.  Inserting coefficients now allows students to make sure that matter is neither created nor destroyed. 

Splitting the process into two distinct steps dramatically improves accuracy.  Make them stable.  Then count them.

Notice: none of the subscripts changed during balancing. Only coefficients changed. 

This approach simplifies predicting products in double displacement reactions and reduces errors when balancing chemical equations.

If your students struggle with predicting products, try teaching these as two separate mental operations:

1. Build stability (subscripts).

2. Count atoms (coefficients).

   
   

When students separate chemical logic from arithmetic balancing, predicting products becomes systematic instead of overwhelming.  Splitting the process into two distinct steps dramatically improves accuracy. First build stability. Then count atoms.

---

Want to use a game that teaches balancing ionic charges as a manipulative? Try Who's your ion? What a family-style game that helps kids understand water solubility? Also, Who's your ion? This game can be used in multiple places in your curriculum to quickly connect kids to the subject. Check it out today!

Buy Who's Your Ion?